2008年12月8日 星期一

Homework

Subject: Imagine that you are a manager at a large insurance company. You find out that very soon everyone who applies to your company for health insurance will be given a genetic test to determine how likely they are to develop a genetic illness. The test will tell you which people are most likely to develop a serious genetic disease in the future. In an e-mail to the other managers of company, explin why you agree or disagree with this use of genetic testing.


-----------------------------
Hi all managers,

I heard everyone who applies to our company for health insurance will be given a genetic test to determine how likely they are to develop a genetic illness. I disagree it since everyone has his own human rights. We can't abridge their human rights.

Although the test will tell us which people are most likely to develop a serious genetic disease in the future and then we can decide if they can apply to our company for health insurance or not, or if we need to raise their insurance fee or not. We still can't do it since insurance company and people who insure to our company all need to take the risk. People who has illness need insurance's protection more than healthy people. It's not fair to do genetic test for anyone.

On the other hand to think about this thing, if I need to do genetic test before I insure and I will give up to insure since I don't like to know I will have illness in the future in advance. Insurance is existed to protect the people who "live"; if someone died, insurance can protect his family.

Please consider to abolish this policy from now on. Let insurance to protect everyone, no matter he is poor, rich, illness or healthy. Thanks!

Regards,

Karen

1 則留言:

Adam Tervort 提到...

Here is my corrected copy.
Adam

Hi all managers,
I heard everyone who applies to our company for health insurance will be given a genetic test to determine how likely they are to develop a genetic illness. I disagree with it since everyone has their own human rights. We can't abridge their human rights.

Although the test will tell us which people are most likely to develop a serious genetic disease in the future and then we can decide if they can apply to our company for health insurance or not, or if we need to raise their insurance fee or not. We still can't do it since insurance companies and people who are insured to our company all need to take the risk. People who have illnesses need insurance's protection more than healthy people. It's not fair to do genetic tests for anyone.

On the other hand to think about this thing, if I need to do genetic testing before I can be insured and I will give up to be insured since I don't want to know if I will have an illness in the future in advance. Insurance exists to protect the people who "live"; if someone died, insurance can protect his family.

Please consider abolishing this policy from now on. Let insurance protect everyone, no matter if he is poor, rich, ill or healthy. Thanks!

Regards,

Karen